by Joy Maitland | Aug 12, 2025 | All Employees, Board Members, Board Trustees, CEO, CFO, COO, CIO, Emerging Leaders, General Managers, Heads of Divisions, Human Resources (HR), News & Articles
Balancing Excellence with Sustainability
(Because “high performance” should not mean “high casualties”)
Here is the paradox no one in the boardroom wants to talk about:
Your relentless push for excellence might be the very thing eroding it.
We glorify high standards. We applaud the extra mile. We celebrate the hero who answers emails at 1:00 a.m. But excellence without sustainability is like running a Formula 1 car at top speed without ever changing the tyres — it looks impressive until it does not finish the race.
What the data says
McKinsey’s “Performance through People” research shows that the top-performing companies (“P + P Winners”) do not just demand results — they design systems where employee autonomy, clear challenge from leaders, and inclusive, supportive workplaces all coexist. This combination outperforms high-pressure, low-support environments on both revenue growth and retention.
Goldman Sachs offers an old-school example with a modern twist: their apprenticeship model couples intense performance expectations with coaching, mentoring, and long-term talent development. That mix keeps people sharp and standing.
The uncomfortable truth:
Many leaders think they are building excellence when, in fact, they are building exhaustion. Burnout is not a badge of honour — it is a business risk. The World Health Organization recognises burnout as an occupational phenomenon because it directly undermines performance, creativity, and health.
Three ways to rewrite the playbook:
- Bake recovery into delivery – Treat downtime as part of the performance cycle, not a guilty pleasure.
- Prioritise in public – Share openly what will not be done this quarter so teams know you mean it when you say “focus.”
- Share ownership of excellence – Stop making quality the responsibility of a handful of perfectionists. Train every team member to own standards — and make it safe to flag when those standards are at risk.
Why this matters more than you think
A culture that matches high standards with pacing, wellbeing, and scenario planning sends a signal: We win the long game. And that is where true competitive advantage lives.
The question to wrestle with: If your team sustained your current pace for the next 24 months, would you still have the same people — and the same quality — at the end of it? If you hesitate, your “excellence” might already be unsustainable.
The Right Conversation Can Change Everything. Let’s Talk.
by Joy Maitland | Mar 30, 2025 | CEO, CFO, COO, CIO, News & Articles
The Rosebud Phenomenon explains how past experiences—especially unresolved emotional wounds—fuel our ambition. It reveals the deep connection between personal history, professional success, and the pursuit of true fulfilment.
In today’s high-performance business environment, professionals chase success with unwavering focus. Success is widely seen as the ultimate benchmark. However, behind many top performers lies a deeper, often hidden force. This powerful motivator is rarely discussed in boardrooms or biographies. It’s here that the Rosebud Phenomenon offers a fresh and enlightening perspective.
What Is the Rosebud Phenomenon?
The Rosebud Phenomenon refers to the idea that a formative trauma, loss, or emotional void becomes the nucleus of ambition. These early experiences often drive us to achieve, push harder, and stand out. They can sharpen determination and shape professional identity. Yet, this same force may quietly limit long-term satisfaction.
The concept originates from the film Citizen Kane. In it, “Rosebud”—a childhood sled—symbolises lost innocence and a deep emotional need that was never resolved. Likewise, many professionals carry a silent narrative rooted in personal history. This narrative becomes the engine behind relentless performance.
A Double-Edged Sword
Understanding the Rosebud Phenomenon helps leaders and entrepreneurs look beyond surface-level motivation. On the one hand, it drives innovation, ambition, and resilience. On the other, it can keep individuals trapped in a cycle of never-enough.
Executives often feel caught in this paradox. The urge to prove themselves, to heal old wounds, or to rewrite personal stories can deliver impressive results. However, when the emotional source remains unexamined, the journey can lead to burnout, chronic dissatisfaction, or identity conflict.
For example, a leader who grew up feeling overlooked might build a wildly successful company—only to discover they still feel invisible.
The Link Between Meaning and Purpose
The Rosebud Phenomenon offers a clear lens to distinguish meaning from purpose.
Purpose tends to be external—a goal, a title, a mission. Meaning, however, is personal. It’s the internal story we attach to what we do and why we do it.
When professionals build their purpose on unresolved emotional meaning, the two can drift apart. This misalignment often explains why some high achievers feel empty despite checking every box.
They hit the targets. They gain recognition. But the satisfaction fades quickly—because the emotional need behind the success remains unmet.
Implications for Leadership and Growth
Recognising the Rosebud Phenomenon unlocks a deeper level of leadership. It encourages authenticity, emotional insight, and a more human approach to performance. By exploring this dynamic, leaders can align their ambitions with true well-being—not just metrics.
Here are three reflective questions to explore:
- What early experiences shaped my need to succeed?
- Does my definition of success reflect what truly matters to me?
- Am I chasing goals to fill a void—or to express genuine passion?
These questions help shift focus from achievement alone to a more sustainable and satisfying kind of success.
A Personal Note
Some years ago, I had the opportunity to attend a workshop with Dr Stewart Desson, founder of Lumina Learning. The session centred on Lumina Emotion—a tool designed to help individuals understand, adapt, and manage their emotions effectively, empowering them to think clearly and act with purpose. During one of the exercises, I experienced what I can only describe as my own Rosebud moment. It was deeply emotional, completely unexpected, and, if I’m honest, a little embarrassing—especially as a business psychologist who’s facilitated similar sessions myself. Yet in that moment, something shifted. My understanding of my own drivers turned upside down, and the clarity it brought was profound. That experience didn’t just stay with me—it quietly changed the way I view success, fulfilment, and what truly matters.
Final Thoughts
The Rosebud Phenomenon in business provides a compelling framework for rethinking motivation. It invites professionals to look inward—not just upward. In a culture that often celebrates output over insight, this shift is both timely and necessary.
For leaders who seek excellence and inner peace, understanding this dynamic offers a powerful advantage. True success doesn’t just come from what we achieve—but from understanding why we strive in the first place.
The Right Conversation Can Change Everything. Let’s Talk.
